US seeks “get-out clause” for illegal farm payments
The US is maneuvering at world trade talks in Geneva this week to insert a special clause in trade negotiations that would make its illegal use of farm subsidies immune from prosecution, international agency Oxfam said today.
The euphemistically named “Peace Clause” is better described as a “get-out clause” or a “license to dump” heavily subsidized farm goods, because it prevents other WTO member countries from challenging the farm subsidies through the WTO dispute settlement process.
Celine Charveriat, head of Oxfam’s Make Trade Fair Campaign, said: “A new Peace Clause would be scandalous. Giving immunity from legal challenges gives the green light to the US and EU to break the rules, leading to market distortions that hurt poor farmers. This is another nail in coffin for development in this Round.
“A new Peace Clause will be a step back for development. The US and EU currently pay at least $13bn (Oxfam’s Truth or Consequence Briefing Paper, 2005) worth of illegal subsidies for agriculture. If the Peace Clause were reintroduced, no poor country would be able to take them to the WTO court for this, for possibly up to 10 years.”
Pascal Lamy, director general of the WTO, admitted yesterday that even though the Peace Clause was not part of the Doha Mandate, and isn’t in the framework agreement (or modalities), it is still likely to be included in the final deal. It’s expected that the EU would not oppose any such move and some EU members have already said that they need it in a Doha agreement.
“Members of the WTO, including the EU, should recognize this outrageous goalpost-shifting and stand against the peace clause effort,’ said Charveriat. “The Doha Mandate laid out what was, and was not, going to be included in this round of trade talks. You can’t just put something on the table at the last minute that totally undermines what has already been agreed,” said Charveriat.
The US said last week that it needs the Peace Clause to be renewed to protect itself from litigation while it is in the process of reducing its trade-distorting subsidies. But instead of cutting subsidies, its current Doha proposal would actually allow the US to increase its farm support from $19.7bn (2005 level) to $22.7bn. Similarly the EU offer would allow it to increase its farm subsidies from $22.9bn (post CAP estimate) to $33.1bn.
Oxfam International analysis shows that 38 developing countries are suffering from unfair competition as a result of trade distorting subsidies by the EU and US, including larger countries such as Mexico and Brazil as well as poor countries like Malawi, Mozambique and West African cotton growing countries.
A new “Peace Clause” would protect US cotton subsidies from further challenges and negotiations on a big reduction in US cotton subsidies are stalled.
“This would mean West African countries could be worse off after a Doha Round than they are now. This is just unbelievable. The EU and US have already shown their willingness to sacrifice this trade round by refusing to address key issues of market access and real subsidy reform,” added Charveriat.
The Peace Clause was introduced at the eleventh hour during the Uruguay Round as a “take-it-or-leave-it” condition for signing a deal. After protecting illegal subsidies for nine years, that Peace Clause elapsed in 2003. While the details of a new Peace Clause are not known it is almost certain that it would block developing countries from taking a raft of new cases to the WTO.
For more information, please contact:
Harriet Binet +44 (0) 7786 110054, or
Romain Benicchio +41 797979 990
Thx for speaking up for women: @MarsGlobal,#Mondelez & @Nestle have now moved from words 2 action http://t.co/laFtaWajFI #BehindTheBrands18 hours 44 min ago
UN agency and Slow Food group partner to boost livelihoods of small farmers http://t.co/l0YMT9yyk8 @SlowFoodHQ1 day 52 min ago
RT @oxfamgbpress: Oxfam very relieved that Cyclone #Mahasen did not cause damage to vulnerable communities in Myanmar http://t.co/t2VwONPjs01 day 1 hour ago
RT @annamac33: The #ArmsTreaty can create a safer future for millions. Urge the US to sign! http://t.co/HRlNC8BcO31 day 2 hours ago
#FF Oxfam Global Ambassadors @KristinDavis @GaelGarciaB @driverminnie @liviafirth @baabamaal @HelenLMirren @BoseOfficial1 day 2 hours ago
#FF Oxfam Global Ambassadors @AnnieLennox @djimonhounsou @angeliquekidjo @firthcom @coldplay @RahulBose1 http://t.co/rXOrgldjlt1 day 2 hours ago
Thanks for speaking up for women! @MarsGlobal #Mondelez & @Nestle have moved from words to action http://t.co/pMvtbhesPh #BehindTheBrands1 day 4 hours ago
#FF the Oxfams! @IntermonOxfam @OxfamIndia @OxfamJapan @oxfamnovib @OxfamQuebec @Oxfam_mcm @OxfamItalia @oxfam_sol @oxfamfrance1 day 5 hours ago
#FF the Oxfams! @OxfamIreland @oxfamcanada @OxfamAustralia @Oxfam_DE @OxfamAmerica @oxfamgb @oxfamnz @oxfamhongkong @oxfammexico1 day 5 hours ago
Dismal levels of investment in agriculture a primary reason 1 in 8 people in the world are hungry http://t.co/orbRUxuVQo #govspendwatch1 day 20 hours ago
'A Jungle of Humanity - and Disorder', an interactive feature from @nytimes http://t.co/DxmATtGICV #SyriaCrisis #Zaatari1 day 21 hours ago
RT @benphillips76 How to Start Development’s Gutenberg Revolution http://t.co/DbieZs9UBZ #govspendwatch1 day 22 hours ago
Social protection, #genderequality & #climatechange crucial to tackling inequality http://t.co/mKqSIBcceM via @guardian #govspendwatch2 days 44 min ago
RT @louis_belanger Starting to see Syrian refugees all over #Beirut On promenade, on Hamra, outside grocery stores, in parking lots #Syria2 days 50 min ago
Are governments meeting their #MDG spending targets? Read the blog http://t.co/3bF1lhH8AX #govspendwatch #MDGs2 days 1 hour ago