Oxfam: WTO agreement a betrayal of development promises
International agency Oxfam today condemned an agreement at the World Trade Organization (WTO) meeting in Hong Kong as failing to deliver on development promises. The agreement reflected rich countries interests far more than those of developing countries and would not deliver the reforms poor countries needed, Oxfam said.
“This is a profoundly disappointing text. Rich countries’ interests have prevailed yet again. The EU and US have betrayed their promises to reform trade rules to promote development and poor countries have had to fight a rearguard action simply to keep some of their issues on the table. Small progress on some aspects of agriculture is more than cancelled out by extremely damaging proposals on services and industry,” said Phil Bloomer, Head of Oxfam International’s Make Trade Fair campaign.
“Developing countries were put in an impossible position. Either to accept a text which is seriously flawed, or face blame for failure. They remained assertive and united during this meeting and clawed back ground from some even worse proposals. However, it is clear that many of them have accepted this text reluctantly,” he added.
Ministers and commentators are assuming that another WTO meeting will take place early next year to finish off the deal but Bloomer warned that “unless rich countries fundamentally change their attitudes to these negotiations no amount of extra time will make a difference.”
In agriculture, the agreement includes a welcome commitment to ensure developing countries have the right to protect products of vital importance to poor farmers. There is also a pledge to eliminate export subsidies and equivalent payments by 2013. But this is three years later than originally hoped and EU export subsidies account for only 3.5% of its overall agricultural support.
Agriculture is the area of the greatest importance to developing countries but the bulk of negotiation remains to be done. The ministerial text does not offer to cut rich countries’ domestic subsidies that cause dumping, nor does it propose tightening the disciplines on allowable payments. There is no guarantee that developing countries will gain significantly greater access to northern markets.
On cotton, the US is offering to eliminate all forms of export subsidies, which is welcome, but this is already required by a WTO ruling and these payments only represent 10% of overall spending. The proposal does not address the core issue of domestic payments that have been proven to distort trade and facilitate dumping.
In the other areas of the negotiations – services and non-agricultural market access – the proposals have gone from bad to worse. The right for poor countries to protect basic services and emerging industries has been comprehensively undermined, with grave prospects for development.
The much vaunted ‘development package’ for the poorest countries has dwindled to include nearly empty offers on aid for trade, with very little new money, and a watered down duty free quota free package that will still allow rich countries to exclude key products vital to the livelihoods of millions of poor people.
Bloomer: “There is nothing free about this offer of duty and quota free access. Rich countries will still be able to protect key products like textiles. It is pathetic that this meeting couldn’t even deliver agreement on a package for the poorest countries”.
For more information, please contact:
Amy Barry, +85295164660;
Marita Wiggerthale (German) +852 95158574;
Laura Rusu, +852 95163305;
Takumo Yamada (Japanese), +852 95168471.
RT @revenuewatch: New @Oxfam post explains what works in the fight against #corruption! http://t.co/1nF9FWykjL via @fp2p46 min 11 sec ago
RT @MeatFreeMonday: The Canadian city of Vancouver will be supporting Meat Free Monday on 10 June! http://t.co/zQ2tfrDX8y2 hours 32 min ago
RT @OxfamAmerica: "I went to Haiti too…" @intldogooder reacts to Nora Schenkel's @NYTimes Op-Ed about #aid in #Haiti: http://t.co/gaCC9xKWWe2 hours 38 min ago
#Syria's #refugees face dire health risks due to lack of shelter, water, basic sanitation http://t.co/s2WBOxn7dI #SyriaCrisis4 hours 24 min ago
5 hours 45 min ago
#Mali emerges as most fragile country in Africa's Sahel region. Displacement & humanitarian funding totals http://t.co/Ro3q9jLKnq @reliefweb6 hours 24 min ago
We’ve come a long way baby… or have we? The 7 #Women's Empowerment Principles http://t.co/g0kFCHOPeD #BehindTheBrands @UN_Women7 hours 4 min ago
Almost 7M people are in need. Life in #Syria's conflict zone: photos http://t.co/ayQ4TgH8wL #SyriaCrisis9 hours 18 min ago
Oxfam warns of health risks to #Syria #refugees as summer approaches http://t.co/hyO0oLc3OW Pls support our #SyriaCrisis appeal9 hours 47 min ago
+80 countries pledged aid at last wk's #MaliConference, including an add'l $32M from the US http://t.co/WCukv0SV7x10 hours 33 min ago
Thx for speaking up for women: @MarsGlobal,#Mondelez & @Nestle have now moved from words 2 action http://t.co/laFtaWajFI #BehindTheBrands2 days 23 hours ago
UN agency and Slow Food group partner to boost livelihoods of small farmers http://t.co/l0YMT9yyk8 @SlowFoodHQ3 days 5 hours ago
RT @oxfamgbpress: Oxfam very relieved that Cyclone #Mahasen did not cause damage to vulnerable communities in Myanmar http://t.co/t2VwONPjs03 days 6 hours ago
RT @annamac33: The #ArmsTreaty can create a safer future for millions. Urge the US to sign! http://t.co/HRlNC8BcO33 days 7 hours ago
#FF Oxfam Global Ambassadors @KristinDavis @GaelGarciaB @driverminnie @liviafirth @baabamaal @HelenLMirren @BoseOfficial3 days 7 hours ago